On Wed, 2006-10-18 at 09:42 -0500, Jason L Tibbitts III wrote:
>>>>> "RC" == Ralf Corsepius
RC> This case clearly violates:
Except that it's firmware.
C.f. below: I am questioning the separation between "firmware" and
RC> and also is not covered by
It seems to me that it is.
"Some applications and drivers require binary-only firmware to
OK, this is an application (an emulator) which requires the host
system's binary firmware in order to function.
"The files are non-executable (note: this means that the files cannot
run on their own, not that they are just chmod -x)"
Only a matter of mime-types, resp. of the way an emulator is being
"The files are not libraries."
Irrelevant. Traditional libraries (ar-archives) are just a form of
"The files are standalone, not embedded in executable or library
Irrelevant, implementation detail.
Such images can easily be transformed between different representations.
Technically it doesn't matter if they are loaded from external files
into memory or are directly embedded into a application's memory.
"Explicit permission is given by the owner to freely distribute
without restrictions (this permission must be included, in "writing",
with the files in the packaging)"
"The files must be necessary for the functionality of open
being included in Fedora."
I assume you disagree with one or more of these, but I'm not sure
RC> These ROMs aren't a linux system's firmware, these are a foreign
RC> system's firmware, to be interpreted by an interpreter (emulator).
Precisely. Are you drawing the distinction between firmware that is
executed by hardware that that which is executed by emulated hardware,
Absolutely not. I am not questioning allowing such binaries (I am all
for it), I am questioning the Fedora Packaging Guidelines.
I consider the separation of firmware from "other binaries" inside of
the FPG to be nonsensical and the criteria above to be nonsensical, and
wish we (FPC) were able to find better criteria.
Consider, an emulator's "firmware" from a Linux's system's
is not any different from other "binary shipped applications" to be run
on an interpreter.