On Sun, May 3, 2009 at 8:08 AM, Matthew Garrett <mjg(a)redhat.com> wrote:
There's absolutely nothing wrong with any of this, but right now
kind of hard to see how moblin is anyone other than Fedora with changes.
I don't think that puts Intel under any sort of obligation to feed
changes back to us and I agree that Koji isn't ideally suited to
producing the kind of derivative that Intel want to, but it would be
nice to acknowledge the amount of the project that's built on the work
of Fedora contributors.
There is more than a touch of irony here, as in the past Fedora
packagers have been on occasion have ruffled feathers of 3rd party by
using 3rd party specfiles as a starting point for a package view for
inclusion into Fedora. We certainly aren't in a position to demand
any sort of official recognition. But at the same time we aren't
restrained from point out that our process is influential.
I guess ideally I'd like to see it work like how rock bands influence
each other. To be an influential rock band, that inherently means
that other bands come up behind you and take your style of doing
things along with pieces of other bands that have influenced them and
make something new. The more influential a rock band you are, the
more rock bands you influence. Doesn't mean you were packing football
stadiums with fans..it means the other artists and the potential
artists..the creators of value..were directly impacted by your work
and incorporated it into their own. And of course those newer rock
bands don't spend all that much time making it a point that they were
influenced by other bands. Sure if they are directly asked in an
interview they'll gladly talk about it..but in general they don't
spend 15 minutes in their shows stepping through their evolution as
artists. The fans that care can hear the influences in the new band's
music. The question is, can moblin contributors hear/feel/smell/taste
the influence from Fedora in the work moblin is doing?
-jef"So basically what I'm saying is.... maybe Fedora is open source's
The Ramones... and moblin is headed towards being U2 or maybe