On 02/26/2010 05:36 PM, Garrett Holmstrom wrote:
On 2/26/2010 6:16, Kevin Kofler wrote:
One possibility could be allowing pushes to stable if one of the
following is true:
* Net karma of at least +x
* Positive karma from at least one member of QA or releng
* At least y days have passed since submission to testing
* The overwhelming number of packages doesn't receive any feedback.
* In cases package updates approach particular issues, testing feedback
is performed though bugzilla in correspondence on actual bugs.
That last case is important for packages with few, if any, testers
that
provide feedback. I own one of those, for instance.
* In all these years, I maintain ca. 70 packages in Fedora, I received
ca. 5 karma votes.
* In all these years, I participate in Fedora, I casted ca. 5 karma
votes. Ca. 3 of them were negative votes and have been ignored by the
maintainer in charge.
=> IMO, this karma system doesn't work at all.
Ralf