On Mon, 1 Mar 2010, Doug Ledford wrote:
One could argue that the current bodhi karma system is simply too
simplistic for real use cases. Maybe instead of just +1 -1, there
should be:
Fixes my problem
Works for me (someone testing that didn't necessarily have any of the
problem supposedly fixed by this update just noting that their system
still works ok with the update)
Doesn't fix my problem (but doesn't necessarily imply it's any worse
than before)
Causes new problems (which should, IMO, be an automatic veto of any push
to stable, requiring intervention to override)
Oh yes. Even just a big red REGRESSION button that stops the update from
automatically entering stable no matter what the karma votes happen to be
would be a definite improvement. And the other data points would certainly
be useful if/when an update happens to get comments.
- Panu -