Howdy, all -
I have purchased a DVD for my kids, and I want to make it available on their tablet for car trips and the like. Totally legal, not pirating, blah, blah, blah.
I've always used handbrake to rip an mp4 file for this, but this particular DVD seems to be copy protected somehow. It's "From Up On Poppy Hill," from Studio Ghibli.
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Thanks, Thomas
2016-04-01 5:02 GMT+02:00 Thomas Cameron thomas.cameron@camerontech.com:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be
If you have the dvd you have the right to do copies for yourself. Long story short, don't bother yourself and just download the movie, won't be pirating since you own it. In my opinion it is a much faster and simpler solution.
Thomas Cameron:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be
thibaut noah:
If you have the dvd you have the right to do copies for yourself. Long story short, don't bother yourself and just download the movie, won't be pirating since you own it. In my opinion it is a much faster and simpler solution.
While that *may* be technically true, in some circumstances, that doesn't stop you from being automatically identified and punished as an illegal downloader. If your country or ISP punishes movie downloaders from non-legal *sources*, I wouldn't do that.
As far as Thomas is concerned, I haven't tried this with copyguarded DVDs, but if you can play the disc with something like VLC, it can stream what it can play to a file. The stream should be the decoded version, not the scrambled data directly from the disc.
On 03/31/2016 10:44 PM, Tim wrote:
As far as Thomas is concerned, I haven't tried this with copyguarded DVDs, but if you can play the disc with something like VLC, it can stream what it can play to a file. The stream should be the decoded version, not the scrambled data directly from the disc.
It won't play via VLC at all, even with libdvdcss installed.
On Fri, 2016-04-01 at 05:22 +0200, thibaut noah wrote:
2016-04-01 5:02 GMT+02:00 Thomas Cameron <thomas.cameron@camerontech. com>:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be
If you have the dvd you have the right to do copies for yourself. Long story short, don't bother yourself and just download the movie, won't be pirating since you own it. In my opinion it is a much faster and simpler solution.
While that may be true, I'd like to see you explain it to a court. (Hint: logic has nothing to do with it).
poc
On 03/31/2016 10:22 PM, thibaut noah wrote:
2016-04-01 5:02 GMT+02:00 Thomas Cameron <thomas.cameron@camerontech.com mailto:thomas.cameron@camerontech.com>:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not beIf you have the dvd you have the right to do copies for yourself. Long story short, don't bother yourself and just download the movie, won't be pirating since you own it. In my opinion it is a much faster and simpler solution.
My ISP sees that differently. :-(
On 04/01/16 11:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Howdy, all -
I have purchased a DVD for my kids, and I want to make it available on their tablet for car trips and the like. Totally legal, not pirating, blah, blah, blah.
I've always used handbrake to rip an mp4 file for this, but this particular DVD seems to be copy protected somehow. It's "From Up On Poppy Hill," from Studio Ghibli.
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
In the past, before all my DVD players died, I used "dvdrip" (available in the rpmfusion repo) to perform this function. As long as I have libdvdcss installed I didn't have problems with copy protected media.
On 03/31/2016 10:45 PM, Ed Greshko wrote:
In the past, before all my DVD players died, I used "dvdrip" (available in the rpmfusion repo) to perform this function. As long as I have libdvdcss installed I didn't have problems with copy protected media.
dvdcss is installed, and dvdrip gives me:
Job 'Read TOC (lsdvd)' failed with error message: Error reading table of contents. Please check your DVD device settings in the Preferences and don't forget to put a DVD in the drive. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 16/03/31 22:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
http://negativo17.org/handbrake/
Niels
On 03/31/2016 11:23 PM, Niels Kobschaetzki wrote:
On 16/03/31 22:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Handbrake errors out. Sorry, thought I'd mentioned that is my usual go-to.
On 16/04/01 09:23, Thomas Cameron wrote:
On 03/31/2016 11:23 PM, Niels Kobschaetzki wrote:
On 16/03/31 22:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Handbrake errors out. Sorry, thought I'd mentioned that is my usual go-to.
You need to use MakeMKV from that link and then you use Handbrake for converting from I guess mpeg2/MKV to m4v. MakeMKV ripped until now everything for me incl. those Disney-DVDs which made problems with pretty much anything else.
Niels
On 04/01/2016 09:35 AM, Niels Kobschaetzki wrote:
On 16/04/01 09:23, Thomas Cameron wrote:
On 03/31/2016 11:23 PM, Niels Kobschaetzki wrote:
On 16/03/31 22:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Handbrake errors out. Sorry, thought I'd mentioned that is my usual go-to.
You need to use MakeMKV from that link and then you use Handbrake for converting from I guess mpeg2/MKV to m4v. MakeMKV ripped until now everything for me incl. those Disney-DVDs which made problems with pretty much anything else.
I did not know about this! Thank you! It seems to be backing up the dvd now, then I'll use ghb to rip it to mp4. Thank you very much!
On Fri, 1 Apr 2016 09:23:19 -0500 Thomas Cameron thomas.cameron@camerontech.com wrote:
On 03/31/2016 11:23 PM, Niels Kobschaetzki wrote:
On 16/03/31 22:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Handbrake errors out. Sorry, thought I'd mentioned that is my usual go-to.
How about makemkv from the same source above. Then use handbrake to convert it to mp4. I often do that when handbrake fails to rip the dvd. Peter
On 04/01/2016 09:47 AM, Peter Reed wrote:
On Fri, 1 Apr 2016 09:23:19 -0500 Thomas Cameron thomas.cameron@camerontech.com wrote:
On 03/31/2016 11:23 PM, Niels Kobschaetzki wrote:
On 16/03/31 22:02, Thomas Cameron wrote:
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Handbrake errors out. Sorry, thought I'd mentioned that is my usual go-to.
How about makemkv from the same source above. Then use handbrake to convert it to mp4. I often do that when handbrake fails to rip the dvd.
This seems to have worked perfectly. Note that I did check the box that says "decrypt disk" or something like that.
I now have an mp4 file for my kid's tablet. Thanks, all!
Thomas
Le 01/04/2016 05:02, Thomas Cameron a écrit :
Howdy, all -
I have purchased a DVD for my kids, and I want to make it available on their tablet for car trips and the like. Totally legal, not pirating, blah, blah, blah.
I've always used handbrake to rip an mp4 file for this, but this particular DVD seems to be copy protected somehow. It's "From Up On Poppy Hill," from Studio Ghibli.
Does anyone know a way of doing this on Fedora? My Google-fu must not be good, as I've found references to this being copy protected, but am only finding links to closed source Windows software to make copies.
Two softs that you can use : k9copy (rpmfusion-free repo) and k3b (fedora repo). The first one rip the dvd and prepare a compressed copy ready to be burnt on a single layer dvd by k3b.
The problem is that video dvd that you can buy are double layer dvd (about 9Gb) and the RW dvd are only 4.7 Gb so you need to compress the data ripped from the video dvd. k9copy does the job.
On 4/1/16, François Patte francois.patte@mi.parisdescartes.fr wrote:
The problem is that video dvd that you can buy are double layer dvd (about 9Gb) and the RW dvd are only 4.7 Gb so you need to compress the data ripped from the video dvd. k9copy does the job.
There's double-layer recordable DVD media since ages.... FYI http://amzn.to/1MYzhdr
FC
On 4/1/16, Thomas Cameron thomas.cameron@camerontech.com wrote:
I've always used handbrake to rip an mp4 file for this, but this particular DVD seems to be copy protected somehow. It's "From Up On Poppy Hill," from Studio Ghibli.
Just checked this title on amazon.com and I see it's available in a "Blu Ray / DVD Combo pack".
If you have a BluRay / DVD reader in your machine, and if per chance you bought this dual-format pack, just make sure you're attempting to rip the DVD version and not the BluRay.
The DVD format has always been easier to "rip". (And btw: since this movie is animation, any difference in image quality will be almost negligible).
FC
you can also try:
dd if=/dev/[dvd device] of=/home/[user]/Video/[Title].iso bs=2048 conv=notrunc
if the write protect fails that then try:
ddrescue -n -b 2048 /dev/[dvd device] [Title].iso
this will create a DVD duplicate ISO file. VLC, available on the tablets, will play this easy, and it functions just like the disk; menus, extra features, etc.
I apologize for the top post.
On Fri, Apr 1, 2016 at 3:53 AM, Fernando Cassia fcassia@gmail.com wrote:
On 4/1/16, Thomas Cameron thomas.cameron@camerontech.com wrote:
I've always used handbrake to rip an mp4 file for this, but this particular DVD seems to be copy protected somehow. It's "From Up On Poppy Hill," from Studio Ghibli.
Just checked this title on amazon.com and I see it's available in a "Blu Ray / DVD Combo pack".
If you have a BluRay / DVD reader in your machine, and if per chance you bought this dual-format pack, just make sure you're attempting to rip the DVD version and not the BluRay.
The DVD format has always been easier to "rip". (And btw: since this movie is animation, any difference in image quality will be almost negligible).
FC
users mailing list users@lists.fedoraproject.org To unsubscribe or change subscription options: https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/users Fedora Code of Conduct: http://fedoraproject.org/code-of-conduct Guidelines: http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines Have a question? Ask away: http://ask.fedoraproject.org
-
Ed Greshko -
Fernando Cassia -
François Patte -
fred roller -
Niels Kobschaetzki -
Patrick O'Callaghan -
Peter Reed -
thibaut noah -
thomas cameron -
Tim