On Fri, 2008-10-03 at 00:35 -0400, Jens Petersen wrote:
Hi Packagers,
A lot of package reviewers already seem to have their own templates
for doing package reviews, which is fine and well. I was thinking
that this could benefit more reviewers, specially those who review
less frequently or are newer to reviewing, if a link to a reference
review template was added to Packaging/ReviewGuidelines that anyone
could make use of.
I could attach mine, which is just a trimmed version of the must and
should items on the above page with "[]" checkboxes but maybe some of
the top reviewer may have something better or more polished. Anyway
if noone else wants to "throw the first stone" I could open a draft
wiki page where we can flesh it out.
Do we really need this? I'd rather see reviewers, who "switch on their
brains" instead of watching people who are mechanically filling out
forms.
I feel, we already have too many of the latter category in Fedora.
Unfortunately, it's them who tend to be active.
Ralf