-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1
Credit to Martin for creating this mail list, there is no longer a risk to lose track. Following feedback, I made modification for the huge icon version with the zipper. Medium version has issue fixed with blur on the left size which should be no longer visible. Comment is welcome.
- -- Luya Tshimbalanga Graphic & Web Designer E: luya@fedoraproject.org W: http://www.thefinalzone.net
On Mon, 2009-11-16 at 00:27 -0800, Luya Tshimbalanga wrote:
Credit to Martin for creating this mail list, there is no longer a risk to lose track. Following feedback, I made modification for the huge icon version with the zipper. Medium version has issue fixed with blur on the left size which should be no longer visible. Comment is welcome.
The zipper in 48x48 is blurry. The 256x256 still violates the guidelines by having wider outlines than approx. 1px. IMHO the slider needs some '3D-ification' in the 256x256 size, currently it looks too flat. Perhaps make some parts of it transparent (the blackish parts are actually holes in real world, aren't they) and add a little bit of depth (I think top faces might be recognisable at this size)?
Martin
On 20/11/09 05:52 AM, Martin Sourada wrote
The zipper in 48x48 is blurry. The 256x256 still violates the guidelines by having wider outlines than approx. 1px. IMHO the slider needs some '3D-ification' in the 256x256 size, currently it looks too flat. Perhaps make some parts of it transparent (the blackish parts are actually holes in real world, aren't they) and add a little bit of depth (I think top faces might be recognisable at this size)?
Martin
256X256 size has been updated with 1px outline. slider has been given 3D effect with shadow.
Luya
The stroke around the slider doesn't look right. And there are some problems in the corners of the box - they doesn't fit correctly.
// Kris
2009/12/7 Luya Tshimbalanga luya@fedoraproject.org
On 20/11/09 05:52 AM, Martin Sourada wrote
The zipper in 48x48 is blurry. The 256x256 still violates the guidelines
by having wider outlines than approx. 1px. IMHO the slider needs some '3D-ification' in the 256x256 size, currently it looks too flat. Perhaps make some parts of it transparent (the blackish parts are actually holes in real world, aren't they) and add a little bit of depth (I think top faces might be recognisable at this size)?
Martin
256X256 size has been updated with 1px outline. slider has been given 3D effect with shadow.
Luya
echo-icon-theme mailing list echo-icon-theme@lists.fedorahosted.org https://fedorahosted.org/mailman/listinfo/echo-icon-theme
On Mon, 2009-12-07 at 11:26 -0500, Luya Tshimbalanga wrote:
On 07/12/09 02:22 AM, Kris Thomsen wrote:
The stroke around the slider doesn't look right. And there are some problems in the corners of the box - they doesn't fit correctly.
Updated version. Fixed corners issue on 256x256 and 48x48 icons and lighter stroke around slider.
Now some of the borders are blurry (especially in 256x256, but I'd check the zipper in 48x48 as well). Please inspect the pixel grid alignment. Other than that it seems much better :)
Martin
On 09/12/09 02:43 AM, Martin Sourada wrote:
Now some of the borders are blurry (especially in 256x256, but I'd check the zipper in 48x48 as well). Please inspect the pixel grid alignment. Other than that it seems much better :)
Updated version.
On Thu, 2009-12-10 at 01:44 -0800, Luya Tshimbalanga wrote:
On 09/12/09 02:43 AM, Martin Sourada wrote:
Now some of the borders are blurry (especially in 256x256, but I'd check the zipper in 48x48 as well). Please inspect the pixel grid alignment. Other than that it seems much better :)
Updated version.
Could you please do an even closer inspection of the pixel alignment? It's still blurry here and there. I attach screen-shots of some blurry places I've noticed. The last one (blur5, 32x32) looks hard to fix while keeping the hole, so maybe simplify it similarly like the 22x22 variant. Plus, the zipper slider in 256x256 seems a little asymmetric to me.
Martin
PS: I hope I don't bug you too much with the blurriness problems instead of fixing them myself, but I'd like all the contributors to be able to catch these issues themselves (so that we can focus more on the icon design itself) and learning by fixing is the best I can come up with...
echo-icon-theme@lists.fedorahosted.org