On Mon, 2014-04-14 at 10:21 -0400, Paul Wouters wrote:
> Or how would you suggest this is solved. For arguments sake
> SSID: myawesomeopenhotspot
> DHCP provides no domain-name info.
> I CNAME all records to my.hotspot. until authenticated.
If this does not do http(s) redirection, than it is a very very broken
setup. You would also need to block port 53 to prevent people using
220.127.116.11 to bypass your authentication. So I do not see this in the wild
(and I've done the hard work of sitting in many coffee shops for
science). hotspots tend to intercept port 80 to a mini web server that
only serves a redirect, sometimes without any DNS name, often with a DNS
name only resolvable by using their DNS. And that is fully supported by
the current solution.
Many of the captive portals I've seen block all access to anything
except the portal login. You don't get to ping anything, you don't get
to DNS anything (let alone 18.104.22.168) and you certainly don't get to send
traffic outside the portal. Only when you've authenticated does it
release you. Sometimes that's done with VLANs and DHCP renewal,
sometimes it's done internally with firewall rules or something.
But another scenario I've seen: older Netgear routers which intercept
"www.routerlogin.net" as the setup page. The instructions literally
1) connect your computer to the router with a cable
2) go to www.routerlogin.net
3) follow the setup guide instructions
Any idea how dnssec-trigger + unbound would handle this? Since it's
router setup, maybe spawning the whole new window for the "portal" would
work, but you'd want to make sure the window didn't go away or DNS
didn't change until the user was done setting up the router.